Official Google Blog: Microsoft’s Bing uses Google search results—and denies it

Official Google Blog: Microsoft’s Bing uses Google search results—and denies it

Microsoft’s Bing uses Google search results—and denies it

2/01/2011 02:56:00 PM

By now, you may have read Danny Sullivan’s recent post: “Google: Bing is Cheating, Copying Our Search Results” and heard Microsoft’s response, “We do not copy Google's results.” However you define copying, the bottom line is, these Bing results came directly from Google.

I’d like to give you some background and details of our experiments that lead us to understand just how Bing is using Google web search results.

It all started with tarsorrhaphy. Really. As it happens, tarsorrhaphy is a rare surgical procedure on eyelids. And in the summer of 2010, we were looking at the search results for an unusual misspelled query [torsorophy]. Google returned the correct spelling—tarsorrhaphy—along with results for the corrected query. At that time, Bing had no results for the misspelling. Later in the summer, Bing started returning our first result to their users without offering the spell correction (see screenshots below). This was very strange. How could they return our first result to their users without the correct spelling? Had they known the correct spelling, they could have returned several more relevant results for the corrected query.

This example opened our eyes, and over the next few months we noticed that URLs from Google search results would later appear in Bing with increasing frequency for all kinds of queries: popular queries, rare or unusual queries and misspelled queries. Even search results that we would consider mistakes of our algorithms started showing up on Bing.

We couldn’t shake the feeling that something was going on, and our suspicions became much stronger in late October 2010 when we noticed a significant increase in how often Google’s top search result appeared at the top of Bing’s ranking for a variety of queries. This statistical pattern was too striking to ignore. To test our hypothesis, we needed an experiment to determine whether Microsoft was really using Google’s search results in Bing’s ranking.

We created about 100 “synthetic queries”—queries that you would never expect a user to type, such as [hiybbprqag]. As a one-time experiment, for each synthetic query we inserted as Google’s top result a unique (real) webpage which had nothing to do with the query. Below is an example:


To be clear, the synthetic query had no relationship with the inserted result we chose—the query didn’t appear on the webpage, and there were no links to the webpage with that query phrase. In other words, there was absolutely no reason for any search engine to return that webpage for that synthetic query. You can think of the synthetic queries with inserted results as the search engine equivalent of marked bills in a bank.

We gave 20 of our engineers laptops with a fresh install of Microsoft Windows running Internet Explorer 8 with Bing Toolbar installed. As part of the install process, we opted in to the “Suggested Sites” feature of IE8, and we accepted the default options for the Bing Toolbar.

We asked these engineers to enter the synthetic queries into the search box on the Google home page, and click on the results, i.e., the results we inserted. We were surprised that within a couple weeks of starting this experiment, our inserted results started appearing in Bing. Below is an example: a search for [hiybbprqag] on Bing returned a page about seating at a theater in Los Angeles. As far as we know, the only connection between the query and result is Google’s result page (shown above).


We saw this happen for multiple queries. For the query [delhipublicschool40 chdjob] we inserted a search result for a credit union:

The same credit union soon showed up on Bing for that query:


For the query [juegosdeben1ogrande] we inserted a page of hip hop bling jewelry:


And the same hip hop bling page showed up in Bing:


As we see it, this experiment confirms our suspicion that Bing is using some combination of:

• Internet Explorer 8, which can send data to Microsoft via its Suggested Sites feature
• the Bing Toolbar, which can send data via Microsoft’s Customer Experience Improvement Program

or possibly some other means to send data to Bing on what people search for on Google and the Google search results they click. Those results from Google are then more likely to show up on Bing. Put another way, some Bing results increasingly look like an incomplete, stale version of Google results—a cheap imitation.

At Google we strongly believe in innovation and are proud of our search quality. We’ve invested thousands of person-years into developing our search algorithms because we want our users to get the right answer every time they search, and that’s not easy. We look forward to competing with genuinely new search algorithms out there—algorithms built on core innovation, and not on recycled search results from a competitor. So to all the users out there looking for the most authentic, relevant search results, we encourage you to come directly to Google. And to those who have asked what we want out of all this, the answer is simple: we'd like for this practice to stop.

Posted by Amit Singhal, Google Fellow

Girl, 10, becomes youngest to discover supernova – This Just In - CNN.com Blogs

Too cool. You go girl! ;)

Girl, 10, becomes youngest to discover supernova – This Just In - CNN.com Blogs

Girl, 10, becomes youngest to discover supernova

Kathryn Aurora Gray spotted the new supernova on this image taken on New Year's Eve.

January 4th, 2011

11:04 AM ET

Share

Comments (380 comments)

Permalink

A 10-year-old Canadian girl will head back to school this month with a good case for some extra credit in science: She became the youngest person to discover a supernova during the holiday break.

Kathryn Aurora Gray of Fredericton, New Brunswick, spotted the exploding star, dubbed supernova 2010lt, on Monday from an image taken on New Year’s Eve by a telescope belonging to amateur astronomer David Lane in Stillwater Lake, Nova Scotia. The exploding star is in the galaxy UGC 3378 in the constellation of Camelopardalis.

The Royal Astronomical Society of Canada (RASC) says Kathryn is the youngest person ever to discover a supernova.

"I was very excited to find one. Especially this quick," Kathryn said of her discovery, according to a report in the Vancouver Sun.

Kathryn began her search for a supernova after she learned last year that a 14-year-old has discovered one of the exploding stars, her father, amateur astronomer Paul Gray, told the Toronto Star.

He shares credit for the find – his seventh – with Lane – his fourth, according to the RASC. The find was verified by amateur astronomers in Illinois and Arizona, the society said in a press release.

Supernovas are massive explosions that signal the death of stars many times the size of our sun, according to the RASC. Astronomers look for them by repeatedly scanning images of distant galaxies like UGC 3378, which is 240 million light years from Earth. That means the star explosion seen by the 10-year-old happened 240 million years ago.

Paul Gray told the Toronto Star his daughter found the supernova while checking the fourth of 52 images Lane had emailed to him.

“Kathryn pointed to the screen and said: ‘Is this one?’ I said yup, that looks pretty good,” Paul Gray told the Star.

Post by: CNN's Brad Lendon Filed under: Latest news • Space

Delta Bidding for Bumping Screen

Delta Bidding for Bumping Screen

A Doctor's Disdain for Medical 'Googlers' - NYTimes.com

A Doctor's Disdain for Medical 'Googlers' - NYTimes.com

November 19, 2007, 11:06 AM

A Doctor’s Disdain for Medical ‘Googlers’

By TARA PARKER-POPE

(Jason Lee/Reuters)

Can a patient ever show up at the doctor’s office with too much information?

A doctor’s essay about medical “Googlers” — patients who research their symptoms, illness and doctors on the Web before seeking treatment — suggests they can. The report, which appeared in Time magazine, was written by Dr. Scott Haig, an assistant clinical professor of orthopedic surgery at Columbia University College of Physicians and Surgeons. He begins with a description of a patient he calls Susan, who seems to be clicking on a keyboard as she speaks to him on the phone. “I knew she was Googling me,” he writes.

Dr. Haig’s disdain for her information-seeking ways becomes quickly evident. He describes the woman’s child, whom she brings to the office, as “a little monster” and notes that the woman soon “launched into me with a barrage of excruciatingly well-informed questions.” Every doctor knows patients like this, he writes, calling them “brainsuckers.”

Susan had chosen me because she had researched my education, read a paper I had written, determined my university affiliation and knew where I lived. It was a little too much — as if she knew how stinky and snorey I was last Sunday morning. Yes, she was simply researching important aspects of her own health care. Yes, who your surgeon is certainly affects what your surgeon does. But I was unnerved by how she brandished her information, too personal and just too rude on our first meeting.

The problem, Dr. Haig notes, is that patients can have too much information and often don’t have the expertise to make sense of it. “There’s so much information (as well as misinformation) in medicine — and, yes, a lot of it can be Googled — that one major responsibility of an expert is to know what to ignore,” Dr. Haig writes.

Dr. Haig’s essay, however, has riled patient advocates, who believe patients need to arm themselves with information and take charge of their own medical care. Mary Shomon, who runs a popular thyroid disease blog on About.com, recently highlighted the essay on her site, generating angry responses from readers. Ms. Shomon said she thinks many physicians like Dr. Haig are threatened by patients who use Google and other Internet resources to research their own health questions.

“By condemning Googlers, he made it clear that he’s threatened by empowered, educated and assertive patients who do their own research,” said Ms. Shomon. “He can’t handle a patient who talks and doesn’t just listen. Good patients…are seen and not heard, right?”

Dr. Haig concludes his essay by confessing that he decided not to treat the woman, whom he described as “the queen of all Googlers.”

I couldn’t even get a word in edgewise. So, I cut her off. I punted. I told her there was nothing I could do differently than her last three orthopedists, but I could refer her to another who might be able to help.

• E-mail This
• Print
• Share
• Twitter
• Recommend

Doctors and Patients, Doctors, google, Internet

Related Posts

FROM WELL

• Can We Trust Google With Our Medical Records?

• The Doctor Is Online

• Doctors Take On a Notorious E-Mail

• Medical Googlers, Part Two

• New From Google: The Body Browser

New From Google: The Body Browser - NYTimes.com

New From Google: The Body Browser - NYTimes.com

RESEARCH FITNESS & NUTRITION MONEY & POLICY VIEWS HEALTH GUIDE

December 23, 2010, 3:52 PM
New From Google: The Body Browser
By SINDYA N. BHANOO

Six years ago, I took a hard fall while playing soccer and tore a ligament in my knee.

As I weighed my treatment options in confusion, I searched on the Internet for images and videos to help me better understand how the knee works.

I wish I’d had access to Google’s Body Browser, a new, free 3-D tool that lets users rotate the body, peel back layers of it, and zoom in and zoom out, all from within an Internet browser window. There’s a search feature, so I typed in “anterior cruciate ligament” and it zoomed into the part of the knee that I’d injured.

It’s like a Gray’s Anatomy coloring book, come to life. I was curious, though, about what medical practitioners think about it. Is it something that medical students might use, or that doctors might use to educate patients?

When I talked to doctors who have played around with Body Browser, they said that isn’t nearly as detailed or sophisticated enough for a medical student. But, many told me, it may end up being an excellent teaching tool for patients.

“I could well imagine that this could replace the innumerable line drawings I’ve done on paper and on endless pairs of scrubs,” said Dr. Ziv Haskal, the chief of vascular and interventional radiology at the University of Maryland Medical Center. “If I could put it up on my iPad or local computer in front of them, that could be very useful.”

Keith Walker, a chiropractor in England, is already using the tool in his clinic. And so far, it’s been a hit.

“As a patient education tool, it’s one of the best I’ve seen,” he said. “There are other things like this on the Web, and they tend to be not as usable, or on medical university Web sites and directed at students.”

Mr. Walker wishes that the 3-D model had limbs that rotated. For example, users can’t lift the wrists of the model, which happen to block a portion of the hip.

The browser also lacks the sort of detail a serious student would need, he said. “If you look at the shoulder, you can’t peel off the layers,” he said. “There are some really important muscles under the deltoid, and you can’t see those.”

Dr. Haskal, too, had a couple of requests. “If we could modify or customize to demonstrate certain diseases, the way you can lay your own map on Google Maps, it would be wonderful,” he said.

Dr. Roni Zeiger, Google’s chief health strategist and an urgent-care physician, was reluctant to share too many details about what’s to come with the Body Browser, but he welcomes suggestions.

“We love all kinds of information, including visual information. And we built this to let anyone who’s curious about anatomy explore it,” he said. “We’ve gotten wonderful feedback from students, patients, teachers, physical therapists and doctors at all levels of training.”

He did say that Google plans to introduce a male model soon. Currently, the browser displays only a female body.

My own request? For the search bar to handle colloquial terms for body parts. Right now, you need to type in medical terms like “gastrocnemius” or “scapula” rather than commonly used ones like “calf” or “shoulder.”

I’m also wondering if one day I’ll be able to map my electronic health record directly to a 3-D model, so that I can visually track any ailments I might have. I reported on a similar technology in Denmark earlier this year.

Try it out if you’d like, and then please join the discussion below. What do you think of Body Browser? What works? What’s lacking?

Note: To use it, you’ll have to install the beta version of the Google Chrome browser, Mozilla Firefox 4 beta or another browser that supports WebGL, which allows for 3-D graphics to be displayed within a browser’s window. You can find those on the Google Body page.
E-mail This Print
Share
Twitter
Recommend
Body Work, google
Related Posts

FROM WELL
Can We Trust Google With Our Medical Records?
A Doctor’s Disdain for Medical ‘Googlers’

New Electric Car Pays For Itself : Discovery News

New Electric Car Pays For Itself : Discovery News

Researchers converted a Scion xB to feed electricity directly into the power grid.
AP Photo

THE GIST:

• A converted Scion is the first electric car to be linked to the power grid.
• The car utilizes vehicle-to-grid (V2G) technology, which uses electricity and gas to store energy and feed it back into the grid.
• V2G is still a new concept, but it is gaining ground in the U.S. and Europe.

---

U.S. researchers unveiled a vehicle Thursday that earns money for its driver instead of guzzling it up in gasoline and maintenance costs.

The converted Toyota Scion xB, shown at the annual meeting of the American Association for the Advancement of Science here, is the first electric car to be linked to a power grid and serve as a cash cow.

"This is the first vehicle that's ever been paid to participate in the grid -- the first proof of concept vehicle," Ken Huber, who oversees technological development at wholesale electricity coordinator PJM Interconnection, told AFP.

The presentation of the box-like, unassuming looking Scion was the researchers' way of introducing the "vehicle-to-grid" (V2G) concept as it begins to gain momentum in the United States and around the world.

WATCH VIDEO: V2G technology can turn an electric car into a moving power station. Willett Kempton, the man behind the concept, explains.

Related Links:

---

• Wide Angle: V2G Technology
• Visualizing the Electric Car 2015
• HowStuffWorks.com: Grid Energy
• Electric Car Charging Stations En Route

---

V2G projects with hybrid cars that use electricity and gas to store energy in their batteries and feed it back into the power grid are up and running in the United States, and the drive now is to produce all electric vehicles to plug into the power grid.

"This makes the car useful not only when it's being driven, but also when it's parked, as long as you remember to plug it in," said Willett Kempton, who is leading a V2G project at the University of Delaware.

A V2G car is connected via an Internet-over-powerline connection that sends a signal from inside the car's computer to an aggregator's server.

The aggregator acts as the middleman between the car owner and power grid management companies, which are constantly trying to keep electricity output at a constant level.

When the grid needs more power due to a surge in demand, power companies usually draw from traditional power plants, which in the United States are often coal-fired and leave a large carbon footprint.

When V2G becomes more widespread, the power could be drawn from millions of vehicles plugged into sockets in home garages or from commercial fleets, such as the U.S. Postal Service's vans, for a much smaller footprint than that of the power plants.

Grid management companies like PJM Interconnection currently pay around 30 dollars an hour when taking power from a car.

V2G is still a new concept, but it is gaining ground in the United States and Europe.

"Ten years ago, this was just a plan. Today, it's a real project and in 10 years, we'll be producing tens of megawatts of power this way," said Kempton, adding that V2G will readily find applications in countries that are rapidly ramping up reliance on wind and solar energy, such as Denmark and Britain.

Huber said he will be meeting in the coming weeks in Paris with heads of European grid management companies about V2G.

"We're going to try to determine how we can work together on this. It's a technology that is very good at meeting a need we have, and there's growing interest among auto companies to develop V2G vehicles," he added.

AC Propulsion of California has designed an electric drive system for V2G, and car manufacturers including Renault/Nissan, Mitsubishi and BMW are producing all-electric vehicles with an eye on the V2G market.